Skip to content
The Blue Collar Marketer
Playbook · Guide Nº 026

Pay-Per-Lead Marketing for Contractors (2026): Angi, HomeAdvisor, Thumbtack, Yelp and Google LSA Compared

How Angi, HomeAdvisor, Thumbtack, Yelp and Google Local Services Ads charge contractors, who else gets the lead, and how bad leads are credited.

Published Nov 17, 2026 · by Luis Gomez

Short answer: Angi, Thumbtack and Google Local Services Ads all charge per lead; Yelp sells pay-for-performance ads it measures in clicks. What decides whether a lead is worth buying is who else gets the same homeowner, who keeps the reviews, and what happens when the lead is junk. Angi matches each request with up to five pros and credits invalid leads toward future charges. Thumbtack charges no membership or subscription fee and calls fees final except as its refund policy says. Google charges when a customer contacts your business directly, credits invalid leads automatically, and takes your review ratings from your own Google Business Profile.

Every rule below comes from the platform’s own help, pricing or terms pages, opened on November 17, 2026 and linked next to the claim. Where a page is silent, I say so instead of filling the gap with someone’s estimate.

The comparison in one table

Angi (and HomeAdvisor) Thumbtack Yelp Ads Google Local Services Ads
How you pay Per lead; the fee varies by task, location and demand (Angi) Per lead, from a budget you set; no membership or subscription fee (Thumbtack) A budget from $5 a day on average (Yelp), measured in clicks (Yelp letter) Per valid lead, never per click (Google)
Who else gets the homeowner Up to five pros per request (Angi) “Limited competition per lead,” no number given (Thumbtack) Not stated on the pages I opened They contact you directly and may contact others (Google)
Your reviews On your Angi profile; five Google reviews can be imported once (Angi) Not stated on the page I opened Not stated on the pages I opened On your Google Business Profile (Google)
Bad leads Account credit for listed invalid reasons, within 45 days (Angi) Fees final except as its refund policy says (Thumbtack terms) Not stated on the pages I opened Automatic credits; you can flag a lead (Google)
Contract An agreement you cancel by phone (Angi) “No hidden fees or contracts” (Thumbtack) No term contract for self-serve (Yelp) None stated; you set the budget and can pause (Google)

Angi, and what became of HomeAdvisor

How you pay. Angi charges a fee for each lead. “Lead fees change based on task, homeowner location, and demand for the work,” and on an Opportunity you see the fee before you accept it (Angi Help Center, October 15, 2026). Your monthly budget is “the target dollar value of leads that Angi will match you with each month”; without an annual subscription you are billed weekly, with one monthly (Angi billing FAQ, March 5, 2026). Leads you take from the Opportunities tab are billed on top of the budget (Angi, August 14, 2026). None of these pages publishes a price.

Who else gets the homeowner. “Each time a homeowner submits a project request, we will match them with no more than five pros” (Angi). So the lead you pay for can also go to up to four competitors.

Your reviews. Reviews on Angi live on your Angi profile. You can import up to five of your Google reviews, and Angi notes “This is a one time import” (Angi, October 15, 2026).

Bad leads. Angi credits a lead with a disconnected or wrong number, a project outside your ZIP codes or services, a second charge for the same homeowner within 45 days, or a charge while your leads were paused. It does not credit a homeowner who doesn’t answer, hired another pro first, decided not to go ahead, or “is gathering multiple quotes.” The lead must be under 45 days old, you should have tried to call within 24 hours, and annual subscribers don’t get credits. Credits are applied to future lead charges and expire if unused for six months; the page doesn’t mention cash refunds (Angi, August 14, 2026).

Contract. Angi calls it an agreement. To cancel, you call its Customer Care team; that page states no notice period and no cancellation fee (Angi, September 2, 2026). Get both in writing before you sign.

HomeAdvisor. The pro site is branded “HomeAdvisor powered by Angi” (pro.homeadvisor.com). The pro help pages for leads, budgets and credits that I could open are Angi’s. If your agreement says HomeAdvisor, ask which rules apply to your account.

Thumbtack

How you pay. Per lead, from a budget you control: “You control your pricing and budget for leads, which determines how many leads you get,” and “There’s no charge to join, no annual fees and no membership fees” (Thumbtack). The pro page publishes no price per lead.

Who else gets the homeowner. Thumbtack advertises “Limited competition per lead” and says you get “leads from customers that choose you” (Thumbtack). That page doesn’t say how many pros a customer can contact.

Bad leads. Thumbtack’s Terms of Use, updated July 10, 2026, say that except as described there or in its Refund Policy, fees paid to Thumbtack “are final and non-refundable” (Thumbtack terms). The Refund Policy sits in Thumbtack’s help center, which did not load for me as readable text, so I’m not summarizing it. Read it before you set a budget.

Contract. “No hidden fees or contracts” and “No subscription cost” (Thumbtack).

Yelp Ads

How you pay. Yelp’s ad page talks about a budget, not a price: “You can spend as little as $5 per day on average” (Yelp). Yelp’s Q2 2026 letter to shareholders (August 6, 2026) counts “clicks on advertisements” and “Request-a-Quote submissions” as the ad clicks of its “pay-for-performance advertising products” and reports an average cost-per-click (Yelp). My reading: you are paying per click, and a quote request counts as one.

Contract. “There are no term contracts with self-serve advertisers,” and “You are free to cancel at any time” (Yelp). The page covers self-serve accounts only.

Who else gets the homeowner, bad leads, reviews. Not stated on the pages I opened. Ask Yelp before you fund it.

Google Local Services Ads

How you pay. “You’re charged for each valid lead you receive through your Local Services ad”: a call you answer or return, a missed call during your business hours where the caller stays on the line for more than 20 seconds, a text or email, a voicemail, or a booking request. Prices “may vary depending on your location, the job type, the type of lead, or your bidding mode” (Google). Google shows its own cost-per-lead estimate in the sign-up flow; here is the five-minute method to get yours.

Who else gets the homeowner. “A lead is a conversion generated when a customer contacts your business directly through your ad” (Google Ads Help). The homeowner can contact other advertisers too: Google lists “Whether the customer has contacted other Local Services advertisers” as a factor in how it prices message leads (Google).

Your reviews. “Your customer reviews are managed through Google Business Profile Manager, not your Local Service Ads account” (Google). They sit on your own profile, not in the ad account.

Bad leads. There is no dispute form. Google “continuously assesses lead quality over a 30-day period” and applies a credit automatically for leads it judges poor quality, duplicate or invalid; you can flag a poor lead in that lead’s feedback survey (Google).

Contract. The Google help pages I read state no contract term. You set an average weekly budget, and “You must pause your ad to stop receiving all leads” (Google).

Who qualifies. Google’s US help article lists 39 home-service categories, with no drywall or pressure-washing category (Google). The ads are moving into Google Ads in 2026, still paid per lead (the migration guide).

Shared and exclusive leads, in plain terms

An exclusive lead goes to you alone. A shared lead goes to several pros at once, so you compete for the same homeowner from the first minute. Angi caps a request at five pros; Thumbtack says competition is limited without giving a number; with Local Services Ads the homeowner contacts you directly and may contact others too. Speed is part of the price: on Angi, a homeowner who hired someone else before you reached them earns you no credit.

What “pay per lead” means when an agency says it

When a marketing agency says “pay per lead,” it can mean three different things. Ask which one before you sign.

  1. They sell you leads. The agency runs its own ads or websites and sells you the contacts at a price per lead. Ask whether the same lead goes to anyone else, what counts as a lead, and what you get back for a bad one.
  2. They run ads in your name and charge per lead. Ask whose ad account and whose phone number it is. If either is theirs, the leads stop the day you leave.
  3. They manage a pay-per-lead platform for you. That is Local Services Ads management: Google bills you per lead from your own account, and the agency charges a fee to run it. The three fee models, compared.

Two questions settle most of it: who owns the account and the phone number, and can you see every raw call and form, not just a monthly total.

Where my offer sits

I’m not a lead seller. I do the third kind of work: I run Local Services Ads, your Google Business Profile and your website in accounts you own, and Google bills you per lead from your own account. That ad budget never touches my hands. My fee is one flat monthly number, quoted on the first call, not a percentage of your ad spend or a cut of your jobs. Your first bill waits until the new jobs have put about double the monthly fee in your pocket. After that it is month to month, in advance, and any paid month where the new work didn’t clear the fee gets refunded. There is no money down: I build first, and if nothing lands, you owe nothing and keep what I built. There is no contract.

What counts as a lead, in the terms’ own words: “A tracked call or form request from the properties I run for you.” On Local Services Ads, Google decides what’s a charged lead, not me. Everything is spelled out on the guarantee page and the pricing page.

One first-party data point

I’m one person with one published case study so far: Patch-It-Now, a drywall repair company in Lee’s Summit, Missouri, owned by my father. These are charged leads from its Local Services Ads billing, after Google’s credits:

Month (2026) Charged leads Lead spend Cost per charged lead
April 22 $1,026.57 $46.66
May 31 $1,286.39 $41.50
June 44 $1,617.81 $36.77
July 52 $2,074.03 $39.89

Read it with the caveats. The account existed before I took over; it launched in January 2026. Drywall has no Local Services Ads category, so it runs under Handyman with only the two drywall job types switched on. Spend rose with volume. It is one trade in one market, not a benchmark for yours, and I have no Angi, Thumbtack or Yelp numbers to put next to it. Every month, with dated screenshots.

Which one for which situation

This part is my opinion, not a platform rule.

Questions owners ask

Is Angi worth it for contractors? It depends on how you close shared leads. Angi matches each request with up to five pros, doesn’t credit homeowners who hired someone else or are collecting quotes, and doesn’t publish its lead prices. Track every Angi lead to a booked job for a month before you raise the budget.

How does Thumbtack pricing work? You pay per lead from a budget you control, with no charge to join and no annual, membership or subscription fee. Lead prices aren’t published on its pro page, and its Terms of Use call fees final and non-refundable except as its Refund Policy says.

Is Google Local Services Ads cheaper than Angi? Neither publishes one price, so the comparison that counts is your own. Google shows an estimated cost per lead for your trade and ZIP in its sign-up flow, and Angi shows the fee before you accept an Opportunity. My one first-party number: drywall on Local Services Ads at $36.77 to $46.66 per charged lead, April to July 2026, in one market.

Are shared leads worth buying? Sometimes, if you call back fast and close well against competition. On Angi, a homeowner who is gathering multiple quotes doesn’t qualify for a credit, so the cost of losing that race is yours.

What happened to HomeAdvisor? Its pro site is branded “HomeAdvisor powered by Angi,” and the pro help pages for leads, budgets and credits that I could open in November 2026 are Angi’s.


Want your lead costs read by someone who publishes his own? Send your trade, your city and what you pay per lead now, and I’ll tell you whether it’s a problem or a bargain, and what I’d change first. Free, whether or not you hire me. Free audit →

More from the Playbook

Want your numbers checked?

Send your trade and your number. I'll look at your ads, your map listing and your site, and tell you the three things I'd fix first — free, whether or not you hire me.

Best way to reach you

Free. No contract. I text or call you back within one business day — usually the same day.

5.0★ · 89 Google reviews on my first client's listing · No money down · You own every account